The Feature comments on the book, Privilege or Punish: Criminal Justice and the Challenge of Family Ties, by Dan Markel, Jennifer Collins, and Ethan Leib, which documents the ways that criminal law advantages and burdens actors based on familial status and identifies the potential harms that are unleashed when criminal law recognizes family status.
Professor Burke’s Feature situates the authors’ observations within the context of two considerations beyond Privilege or Punish’s immediate focus: chronological trends and the practical realities that can shape application of formal law. By distinguishing criminal law’s traditions from contemporary trends, the Feature identifies both a gradual de-emphasis of legally recognized family forms and an increased willingness to enforce criminal law within families, regardless of how they are comprised. It concludes by arguing that effective enforcement of criminal law within families often requires the criminal justice system to yield to family relationships, not for the purpose of promoting preferred family forms, but to serve the criminal law’s familiar retributive and utilitarian goals.
Read the Feature at yalelawjournal.org.