Prof. Eric Freedman Asserts Process of Reversing Death Penalty Convictions Places a High Bar in Front of Defendants

Eric M. Freedman, Maurice A. Deane Distinguished Professor of Constitutional Law

In Death-Penalty Debate, Execution Offers Little Closure

By John Schwartz

The New York Times

September 22, 2011



To Eric M. Freedman, a professor at Hofstra Law School and an expert on the death penalty, the desire for finality is “understandable in some respects,” but the process of reversing convictions places too high a bar in front of defendants. At trial, he said, the state has the burden of proving them guilty, and if “one reasonable juror would have had a reasonable doubt, that would have gotten you acquittal.”

“After conviction,” Professor Freedman said, “the burden shifts to them.”

Thus, he said, the process “allows error to justify error” through its efforts to respect the decisions of juries.

“The system does bury its mistakes,” he said.

Read the full article at nytimes.com.

Eric M. Freedman also discussed the Troy Davis case and the issue of capital punishment on Wisconsin Public Radio’s “At Issue with Ben Merens” on September 22.


Latest Tweets

  • Watch Prof. @jamesjsample discuss articles of impeachment and the latest on the impeachment process with… https://t.co/dsiFA438ol
    about 13 hours ago
  • Prof. Fred Klein Presents to Nassau County District and County Court Judges on New Criminal Discovery Law in New Yo… https://t.co/0gnceVkLZQ
    about 1 day ago
  • Prof. Andrew Schepard Presents on Forensic Parenting Evaluations at 10th Judicial District 3rd Annual Matrimonial C… https://t.co/XEeEnJx6vh
    about 1 day ago
  • Prof. Norman Silber Presents on the ‘Revolt Against the Regulation of Philanthropy’ at 2019 ARNOVA Annual Conference https://t.co/eSw9yEQNHR
    about 1 day ago
  • Article by Prof. Norman Silber on Foreign Interference in National Elections Published in Northwestern University L… https://t.co/xh6W6WYZfP
    about 1 day ago
  • Watch Prof. @jamesjsample discuss the latest regarding the impeachment inquiry with @PIXScott on @PIX11News:… https://t.co/p3nyM9uoc1
    about 2 days ago