Faculty Notes

Prof. Miriam Albert Quoted in Wired Story About Ashley Madison Hack

Miriam R. Albert, Professor of Skills and Faculty Advisor for the J.D./M.B.A. Program

Ashley Madison Hack Exposes (Wait for It) a Lousy Business
By Julia Greenberg
Wired
August 21, 2015

Excerpt:

All of which means, whatever the site’s claims, its apparent gender imbalances probably isn’t enough to call it a scam. “In the law, there’s this idea of puffery. Salespeople, and that’s what they are, are allowed to exaggerate,” says Hofstra University law professor Miriam Albert.

“A saleslady at Lord and Taylor says, ‘That dress looks awesome on you,’ when in reality, you’re packed like a 10-pound sausage into a 5-pound casing. She’s allowed to say that and you can’t sue her for it because you’re not relying on her to make the purchase.”

Similarly, there were some women on the site, so even if there weren’t as many as Biderman publicly claimed, the difference may not be enough to deem it fraud. “If what they’re really saying is ‘It’s evenly split,’ and someone went into it with that basis, I bet you could get your money back,” Albert says. “I’m just not sure it rises to the level of actionable fraud. It’s the cusp between puffery and fraud. It’s a slippery slope.”

Yet the site could be at risk for legal action over its failure to protect the private information of its users—especially those who paid $19 to erase all trace of their connection to the site.

“This is going to be a big legal mess because, putting aside the morality of it, they promised to keep this information safe, and what the lawsuits are going to look at is, did they do enough?” says Albert. “No court is going to require them to guarantee strict liability that no one could ever get to it. It’s really going to come down to what they did, and did they do enough.”

Read the full article.

Latest Tweets

  • Watch Prof. @jamesjsample discuss articles of impeachment and the latest on the impeachment process with… https://t.co/dsiFA438ol
    about 5 days ago
  • Prof. Fred Klein Presents to Nassau County District and County Court Judges on New Criminal Discovery Law in New Yo… https://t.co/0gnceVkLZQ
    about 6 days ago
  • Prof. Andrew Schepard Presents on Forensic Parenting Evaluations at 10th Judicial District 3rd Annual Matrimonial C… https://t.co/XEeEnJx6vh
    about 6 days ago
  • Prof. Norman Silber Presents on the ‘Revolt Against the Regulation of Philanthropy’ at 2019 ARNOVA Annual Conference https://t.co/eSw9yEQNHR
    about 6 days ago
  • Article by Prof. Norman Silber on Foreign Interference in National Elections Published in Northwestern University L… https://t.co/xh6W6WYZfP
    about 6 days ago
  • Watch Prof. @jamesjsample discuss the latest regarding the impeachment inquiry with @PIXScott on @PIX11News:… https://t.co/p3nyM9uoc1
    about 7 days ago

Archives